| | FORMER BLUE FRIARS | | 41 | Conrad Hahn†, bf, Connecticut | 1964 |
| 1 | J. Raymond Shute ii†, bf, N. Carolina | 1932 | 42 | Bernard E. Jones†, bf, England | 1964 |
| 2 | J. Hugo Tatsch†, bf, New York | 1933 | 43 | Norman S. Meese†, bf, Dist. of Col. | 1965 |
| 3 | J. Edward Allen†, bf, N. Carolina | 1934 | 44 | Alphonse Cerza†, bf, Illinois | 1966 |
| 4 | Charles C. Hunt†, bf, Iowa | 1935 | 45 | James D. Carter†, bf, Texas | 1967 |
| 5 | Henry V. A. Parsell†, bf, New York | 1936 | 46 | Allen E. Roberts†, bf, Virginia | 1967 |
| 6 | Ray V. Denslow†, bf, Missouri | 1937 | 47 | Dwight L. Smith†, bf, Indiana | 1968 |
| 7 | Harold V. B. Voorhis†, bf, New Jersey | 1938 | 48 | Henry Emmerson†, bf, New York | 1968 |
| 8 | Arthur E. Waite†, bf, England | 1939 | 49 | Ronald E. Heaton†, bf, Pennsylvania | 1969 |
| 9 | Carl H. Claudy†, bf, Dist. of Col. | 1940 | 51 | Frederick H. Smyth, bf, England | 1970 |
| 10 | Hubert M. Poteat†, bf, N. Carolina | 1940 | 50 | William G. Peacher†, bf, California | 1969 |
| 11 | Melvin M. Johnson†, bf, Massachusetts | 1941 | 52 | Donavon D. Tidwell†, bf, Texas | 1971 |
| 12 | William L. Cummings†, bf, New York | 1942 | 53 | Gerald D. Foss†, bf, New Hampshire | 1972 |
| 13 | Henry Falls Evans†, bf, Colorado | 1943 | 54 | Ralph H. Gauker†, bf, Dist. of Col. | 1973 |
| 14 | Wallace E. Caldwell†, bf, N. Carolina | 1943 | 55 | George A. Newbury†, bf, New York | 1974 |
| 15 | Charles H. Johnson†, bf, New York | 1945 | 56 | Walter M. Callaway†, bf, Georgia | 1975 |
| 16 | Ward K. St Clair†, bf, New York | 1945 | 57 | Mervin B. Hogan†, bf, Utah | 1976 |
| 17 | Clarence Brain†, bf, Oklahoma | 1946 | 58 | Charles E. Green†, bf, Delaware | 1977 |
| 18 | J. Fairbairn Smith†, bf, Michigan | 1946 | 59 | Forrest D. Haggard†, bf, Kansas | 1978 |
| 19 | William Moseley Brown†, bf, Virginia | 1947 | 60 | Richard H. Brown†, bf, New York | 1979 |
| 20 | Harry L. Haywood†, bf, Iowa | 1948 | 61 | George H. T. French†, bf, Texas | 1980 |
| 21 | Robert J. Meekren†, bf, Quebec | 1949 | 62 | Bruce H. Hunt†, bf, Missouri | 1981 |
| 22 | Richardson L. Wright†, bf, New York | 1949 | 63 | Roy A. Wells†, bf, England | 1982 |
| 23 | Reg V. Harris†, bf, Nova Scotia | 1949 | 64 | Wilmer E. Bresee†, bf, New York | 1983 |
| 24 | Francis J. Scully†, bf, Arkansas | 1950 | 66 | Louis L. Williams†, bf, Illinois | 1985 |
| 25 | Howard P. Nash†, bf, New York | 1950 | 67 | F. Lamar Pearson†, bf, Georgia | 1986 |
| 26 | George S. Draffen†, bf, Scotland | 1951 | 68 | Stanley Maxwell†, bf, Massachusetts | 1987 |
| 27 | James E. Craig†, bf, New York | 1952 | 70 | John H. Van Gorden†, bf, Florida | 1989 |
| 28 | Fabian Onsari†, bf, Argentina | 1953 | 71 | Jerald E. Marsengill†, bf, Iowa | 1989 |
| 29 | Edgar A. Guest†, bf, Michigan | 1954 | 72 | Stewart M. L. Pollard†, bf, Maryland | 1990 |
| 30 | Fred Lomax Pick†, bf, England | 1955 | 73 | Keith Arrington†, bf, Iowa | 1991 |
| 31 | James Royal Case†, bf, Connecticut | 1956 | 74 | Allan Boudreau†, bf, New York | 1992 |
| 32 | Charles G. Reigner†, bf, Maryland | 1957 | 75 | Cyril N. Batham†, bf, England | 1992 |
| 33 | A. J. B. Milborne†, bf, Quebec | 1958 | 76 | Charles S. Guthrie†, bf, Kentucky | 1993 |
| 34 | W. Irvine Wiest†, bf, Pennsylvania | 1959 | 77 | John J. Robinson†, bf, Ohio | 1993 |
| 35 | Ray Baker Harris†, bf, Dist. of Col. | 1960 | 78 | Joseph E. Bennett†, bf, Idaho | 1994 |
| 36 | Henry Wilson Coil†, bf, California | 1961 | 80 | Richard H. Curtis†, bf, Massachusetts | 1996 |
| 37 | William Ray Denslow†, bf, Missouri | 1962 | 82 | Joseph A. Walkes Jr†, bf, Kansas | 1997 |
| 38 | Wendell K. Walker†, bf, New York | 1962 | 86 | James T. Tresner ii†, bf, Oklahoma | 1999 |
| 39 | John Black Vrooman†, bf, Missouri | 1963 | 90 | Nelson King†, bf, Ontario | 2001 |
| 40 | Harry Carr†, bf, England | 1963 | 91 | William Preston Vaughn†, bf, Texas | 2002 |
† Deceased